Well...
I've been thinking about writing a post about my feminist inclinations, but Phyllis Schlafly has pushed me over.the.edge. I cannot keep silent about this. I'm pretty positive that this won't be the only response to her rather radical comments about a causal link between income disparity and marriage stability. Just because someone else will be saying it doesn't mean I can keep silent. I'm not that sort of girl.
{For those who haven't read it, here is her op-ed piece without the (righteously) indignant commentary of others.}
First, let me just say:
What the frick frack was that about, ma'am????
Ok, now that I finished with that...
I'm a feminist. I am. It's a label that's tossed around, sometimes as an accusation, sometimes as a commendation. What does it mean, though? What implications does it necessarily have?
Feminism, to my mind, is simply the conviction that women are intelligent and capable. It also means that they are independent. I don't use that word to mean "non-social" and "completely self-sufficient," but simply that women are independent in same way that men are independent.
When you say a man is independent, what do you mean? You mean that he can take care of himself and his needs in a reasonable and expected manner. It doesn't mean he doesn't need a community to help him live a good life. It doesn't mean that he doesn't need a woman for companionship and support. Independence in a man isn't considered to be a bad thing.
So what changes when you transfer that label to a woman? Many traditionalists throw up their hands in despair and say that any woman who considers herself independent is uprooting the foundations of society by casting aside the notion of marriage and family.
That escalated quickly.
A man is allowed to be independent, but to be a woman is to be a dependent? Femininity and dependence aren't the same thing. Masculinity and independence aren't the same thing. Being independent simply means that you aren't a helpless leech that sucks the life and money out of the people around you. It means you have two feet, you can stand on them, and you will stand on them. That's it.
So a woman can be intelligent, capable, and independent. She can view herself as all of these things. This would make her, to my mind, a feminist.
Her values, morality, ideology, etc., are not contingent on this view in a logically necessary manner. Her values, morality, ideology, etc., are prior to - or, at least, separate from - her feminism. They will dictate her reaction to societal injustices, however.
To go all geeky-nerdy on you, Nick Fury, of the Marvel universe, tells Captain America, "S.H.I.E.L.D. takes the world as it is, not as we'd like it to be." This may not seem relevant, but give me a couple hundred words and I'll draw the dotted line for you.
Let's take, for the sake of clarity, although not to start a war on the internets, the case of abortion. Abortion is pushed by many feminists as a way to make women equal to men. How does it do that, exactly? It frees women from the consequences of sex (well, at least the pregnancy consequence - STDs are still problem shared by one and all... yay) so they can continue their lives as planned. Lets leave aside the issues of whether or not you can actually do that (can you really just erase any part of your life like it never happened? Seems unlikely...) and assume for the moment, that you can. Historically, a woman who was impregnated before marriage was a social outcast for the rest of her life. Chew on that for a minute. She was often unable to get work, shunned from all good society, and frequently banned from entering a church.
Where is the man in all this? Off impregnating other women. Or marrying some respectable, "pure and blushing" girl. His life is fine.
That isn't fair, is it?
Taking the world as it is, we can make the men accountable and punish them equally or we make the problem disappear. Clearly, making men accountable wasn't even possible before paternity tests. Even after paternity tests, the stigma associated with out of wedlock pregnancy is heavily prejudiced against women, not to mention that it is ridiculously expensive and complicated to make the man legally responsible in any way. So some feminists "take the world as it is" and formulate a different solution. If there is no pregnancy, there is no societal shame. There are no repercussions on her education or her career. She is able to marry, have a career, have a family, without any "complications." She gets to be equal to men. She gets to walk away, just like he does.
The other alternative that presents itself to a feminist is the one where we take the world "as we'd like it to be." The moral code of society should be dictated by absolute right and wrong, whether or not the world makes that easy and neat.
Like Captain America, this type of feminist resolves to be ethical, moral, and traditional, even at the cost of some messiness. Ok, lots of messiness.
However, choosing the messy doesn't mean we aren't intelligent, capable, independent, self-respecting women. It doesn't mean we don't have ambition, strength, and courage. Hopefully, we won't be literally dying like Cap, but we have to
be willing to die to self. We have to be willing to put our selves aside
for a greater good. This requires intelligence. It requires the
capacity to see and understand and act in a logical, effective, and compassionate manner.
It is necessary for women to be intelligent, capable, and independent.
So, Phyllis, I deny your claims of causality between wage gaps and marriage stability. Any self-respecting woman - conservative or otherwise - doesn't get married for economic stability. She gets married because she loves a man. And yeah, I believe in traditional family roles. I believe that a woman should be able to stay home with her kids while the man supports his family in the workforce. I believe this is rooted in the differences between men and women's psychology, anatomy, and emotional makeup. Ideally, in this traditional family, the man will make more money in his career than the woman did in hers because, well, duh - that makes sense. You should keep the higher income earning spouse in the workforce. You're providing for yourselves and your children. You should be fiscally responsible.
Phyllis, I hate to break this to you, but what you said just sounds stupid. (I'm not saying you're stupid - I don't know you well enough to say whether or not you lack intellectual acumen - but this theory of yours is stupid)
If anything, you hurt the credibility of people who believe in traditional family roles. I am a very traditional person. Being lumped in with a group of people that publishes such silly things doesn't help my dialogue with people on the other side of the political fence.
We have to dialogue. It's necessary. We need societal support to survive as a species. Throwing the argumentative equivalent of custard pies in each others' faces isn't a step forward. It isn't even a stand-still. It's a leap and half backwards.
...
"Upon my word, Emma, it would be better to be without sense than to misapply it as you do." ~Mr. Knightley, Jane Austen's Emma.
Showing posts with label Marriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Marriage. Show all posts
16 April 2014
04 June 2013
Gag Reflex
I have a very sensitive gag reflex. It takes very little to make me gag.
Unfortunately, I don't just gag on dental x-rays. I gag on romance and sentiment. Like this image:
As an aside, I will fall for (probably) any man in military uniform. Just saying. And a kiss on the forehead? Super sweet.
But the quote? GAG. (To get the full effect, read the following with me talking really loud and waving my hands around like the crazy Italian woman I am).
First, the fact that we're all supposed to be striving to be "ideal" is just weird. What does that mean? Is there one archetype that ignores human complexity? (thanks, Kathryn, for that phrase. It hits the nail on the head, I think.)
Second, I just find it way too sentimental, mushy, fluffy, etc. I know that romance can be good. Sentiment, even, can be good. But this kind of romance and sentiment makes my skin crawl.
So what should this photo say?
Maybe something about not fitting an ideal, but being yourself without compromise. That way, those that are attracted to you will be attracted to YOU, not some ideal. If they marry you, they're going to have to live with you - not an ideal.
Maybe something about recognizing your faults and accepting them as a part of who you are. This does not mean that you shouldn't strive to overcome your faults. It means that you accept that you aren't perfect. You have to accept that because it's true. You are not perfect and no one is perfect for you. No one is perfect. Period. We can't be perfect for ourselves and we can't be perfect for each other.
Why not? Because life is messy. Sin made it that way. It's unscripted, disappointing, and messy. The sooner you accept that, the sooner you'll be happy. Stop waiting for the perfect person who matches that checklist you wrote. They're not coming.
You are a sinner. I am a sinner. We're all sinners. With sin, we can't be ideal. With free will and our beautifully, lovingly created souls, we can't all fit one ideal.
Loving is not about being blind to a person's faults. It is not about ignoring them when you notice them. Loving is about accepting the faults as part of the person. It is about forgiving the other person for hurt they cause. It's about second, third, and seventy-times-seven chances.
So stop making gag-worthy photo-catch-phrase combinations. Love is more complicated than a catch-phrase cutely paired with a photo.
I just want a normal guy who loves me and is willing to laugh at me, my strange antics, and, occasionally (maybe more than occasionally), himself. I want a guy who is smart and responsible. I want him to have faults because WHO ON EARTH WANTS TO LIVE WITH AN IDEAL MAN?????
End of rant.
Unfortunately, I don't just gag on dental x-rays. I gag on romance and sentiment. Like this image:
As an aside, I will fall for (probably) any man in military uniform. Just saying. And a kiss on the forehead? Super sweet.
But the quote? GAG. (To get the full effect, read the following with me talking really loud and waving my hands around like the crazy Italian woman I am).
First, the fact that we're all supposed to be striving to be "ideal" is just weird. What does that mean? Is there one archetype that ignores human complexity? (thanks, Kathryn, for that phrase. It hits the nail on the head, I think.)
Second, I just find it way too sentimental, mushy, fluffy, etc. I know that romance can be good. Sentiment, even, can be good. But this kind of romance and sentiment makes my skin crawl.
So what should this photo say?
Maybe something about not fitting an ideal, but being yourself without compromise. That way, those that are attracted to you will be attracted to YOU, not some ideal. If they marry you, they're going to have to live with you - not an ideal.
Maybe something about recognizing your faults and accepting them as a part of who you are. This does not mean that you shouldn't strive to overcome your faults. It means that you accept that you aren't perfect. You have to accept that because it's true. You are not perfect and no one is perfect for you. No one is perfect. Period. We can't be perfect for ourselves and we can't be perfect for each other.
Why not? Because life is messy. Sin made it that way. It's unscripted, disappointing, and messy. The sooner you accept that, the sooner you'll be happy. Stop waiting for the perfect person who matches that checklist you wrote. They're not coming.
You are a sinner. I am a sinner. We're all sinners. With sin, we can't be ideal. With free will and our beautifully, lovingly created souls, we can't all fit one ideal.
Loving is not about being blind to a person's faults. It is not about ignoring them when you notice them. Loving is about accepting the faults as part of the person. It is about forgiving the other person for hurt they cause. It's about second, third, and seventy-times-seven chances.
So stop making gag-worthy photo-catch-phrase combinations. Love is more complicated than a catch-phrase cutely paired with a photo.
I just want a normal guy who loves me and is willing to laugh at me, my strange antics, and, occasionally (maybe more than occasionally), himself. I want a guy who is smart and responsible. I want him to have faults because WHO ON EARTH WANTS TO LIVE WITH AN IDEAL MAN?????
End of rant.
12 February 2013
Thoughts on Marriage (a lighthearted post)
A few of our confirmation kids' responses to "What do you want in a spouse?"
"Wants to have kids."
"Will be faithful."
"Appreciates humor."
"You better be funny." (Yes, this kid wrote in imperatives.)
"Shorter than me." (I believe this one was written by a guy. I hope.)
"Smells good."
"Catholic" (Surprisingly, we only got two of these in the stack of 100 cards we got back.)
"Attractive."
"Attracted." (??)
"Someone who can listen to my problems."
"Don't even think about cheating on me." (Imperative boy again. Ha!)
"Loving."
"Understanding and patient."
"Honest."
"Is intelligent."
"Flexible with her time."
"You better be able to cook."
"Understand sports." (HA!)
"Accent, preferably Spanish."
"Not a vegetarian/vegan."
"Need to have soul." (the girls didn't understand this one)
"Strong." (a trait more than one girl wanted in her spouse, but all of the guys thought was unreasonable)
"VERY attractive."
"Determined and ambitious."
"Dark hair."
"Great set of hair."
"Someone who shuts the bathroom door." (I think this one is my favorite...)
"Appreciates Jesus."
"Able to clean."
"Not obese."
"Silly."
"Nice eyes."
"Caring or sweet (does, like, cute little things)" (Awwww, how cute)
"Optimistic."
We had the guys mark the girl's cards as either reasonable or unreasonable, and had the girls do the same to the guys cards. It was a great way to facilitate discussion and start some thought on the subject.
It also made class very lighthearted and fun. :)
"Wants to have kids."
"Will be faithful."
"Appreciates humor."
"You better be funny." (Yes, this kid wrote in imperatives.)
"Shorter than me." (I believe this one was written by a guy. I hope.)
"Smells good."
"Catholic" (Surprisingly, we only got two of these in the stack of 100 cards we got back.)
"Attractive."
"Attracted." (??)
"Someone who can listen to my problems."
"Don't even think about cheating on me." (Imperative boy again. Ha!)
"Loving."
"Understanding and patient."
"Honest."
"Is intelligent."
"Flexible with her time."
"You better be able to cook."
"Understand sports." (HA!)
"Accent, preferably Spanish."
"Not a vegetarian/vegan."
"Need to have soul." (the girls didn't understand this one)
"Strong." (a trait more than one girl wanted in her spouse, but all of the guys thought was unreasonable)
"VERY attractive."
"Determined and ambitious."
"Dark hair."
"Great set of hair."
"Someone who shuts the bathroom door." (I think this one is my favorite...)
"Appreciates Jesus."
"Able to clean."
"Not obese."
"Silly."
"Nice eyes."
"Caring or sweet (does, like, cute little things)" (Awwww, how cute)
"Optimistic."
We had the guys mark the girl's cards as either reasonable or unreasonable, and had the girls do the same to the guys cards. It was a great way to facilitate discussion and start some thought on the subject.
It also made class very lighthearted and fun. :)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
